| Weight | #3 Coe (0-0, 0-0 IIAC | Central (0-0, 0-0 IIAC) | Result |
| 125 | #3/3 Clayton Rush (2-0) | Justin Marx (3-4) | 25-9 |
| 133 | Bryan Telgenhoff (3-2) | Chris Kilgannon (0-3) | 6-2 |
| 141 | Jordan Westfall (2-3) | Josh Atwell (4-1) | 8-6 |
| 149 | Mark Carey (1-0) | Joe Atwell (1-3) | Fall |
| 157 | Dale Handley (4-3) | Jared Hermann (2-3) | 17-1 |
| 165 | #2/4 Nick LeClere (5-0) | Reid Imerman (3-2) | 16-4 |
| 174 | #7/5 Seth Rehn (3-2) | Tommy Van Renterghem (3-2) | 8-4 |
| 184 | #3/3 Tyler Burkle (4-1) | Forfeit | Forfeit |
| 197 | #4/4 Rob Kramer (3-1) | Theron Stewart (3-3) | Fall |
| HWT | #6/6 Mitch Sander (5-0) | Jake Crawford (2-3) | 3-1 |