11 NCAA Div. III national team championships

Honorees are selected by the College Sports Information Directors of America (CoSIDA).
| Year | Name | Sport |
|---|---|---|
| 1979 | Chris Adkins | Football |
| Brent Aufdembrink | Football | |
| 1983 | Denise Boll | Women's basktball |
| Lisa Broek | Women's track | |
| Tony Carey | Men's golf | |
| 1984 | Denise Boll | Women's basketball |
| 1985 | Sue Poppens | Women's basketball |
| Brian Goldsworthy | Men's golf | |
| Todd Sutphen | Baseball | |
| Scott Lindell | Football | |
| Neil Gray | Football | |
| 1986 | Scott Lindell | Football |
| 1987 | Beth Van Voorhis | Women's tennis |
| 1988 | Shannan Mattiace | Women's tennis |
| Rick Perry | Football | |
| Gregg Gustafson | Football | |
| Dallas Bogner | Men's tennis | |
| 1989 | Rick Hassman | Baseball |
| Shannan Mattiace | Women's tennis | |
| 1990 | Matt Melvin | Men's basketball |
| Shannan Mattiace | Women's tennis | |
| 1991 | Rich Kacmarynski | Football |
| 1992 | Nate Hart | Men's basketball |
| Heather Reedy | Softball | |
| Chris Hulleman | Football | |
| 1993 | Blake Jessen | Men's basketball |
| Heather Reedy | Softball | |
| Mindi Remsburg | Sorftball | |
| Jayna Blom | Women's track | |
| 1994 | *Emilie Hanson | Women's basketball |
| Jason Sanders | Football | |
| 1995 | *Emilie Hanson | Women's basketball |
| Matt Bandstra | Football | |
| 1996 | Ryan Murphy | Men's tennis |
| 1997 | Ryan Murphy | Men's tennis |
| 1998 | Jason Darling | Baseball |
| 2000 | Angie Nielson | Volleyball |
| 2004 | Raegan Schultz | Women's track |
| Jamie Stark | Volleyball | |
| 2005 | Adam Duerfeldt | Baseball |
| Jason Ford | Men's tennis | |
| 2006 | *Adam Duerfeldt | Baseball |
| Nich Cochrane | Men's tennis | |
| Bryan George | Men's track | |
| Ben Bollard | Football | |
| 2007 | Ben Bollard | Men's track |
| 2010 | Jill Ziskovsky | Women's track |
| 2011 | Jill Ziskovsky | Women's track |
| 2012 | Sarah Paulson | Women's golf |
*Academic All-American player of the year
follow us on ...